Misery by William Goldman, directed by Jackson Gay

Dorset Theatre Festival, 2023; Dorset, VT

McAndrew’s strength is taking up each new mood of Annie’s and committing to it fully. Her performance surprises viewers as much as Annie startles Paul. One moment she is a steadfast nurse; next she’s infatuated with the great author who’s created a character she adores; and next she’s capable of merciless oppression. She skillfully underplays the extremes and makes a madwoman lovable by lacing her with just enough humor to keep us more curious than horrified. She pinballs through emotions, truly dangerous because she’s making it all up as she goes along.
— Alex Brown, Seven Days

Dan Butler and Kelly McAndrew

Kelly McAndrew and Dan Butler

Kelly McAndrew and Dan Butler